The three things they're judging, and none of them is your wardrobe
Think of executive presence as the kind of feedback that arrives unannounced and never comes with instructions. You hear that you need more of it, nobody in the room can define it, and before long you are second-guessing your jackets. Pause there. The people assessing it are really weighing three things: whether they can trust you with a decision, whether you get listened to when you talk, and whether you hold steady when things fall apart. Your wardrobe does not factor in. In a way, the vagueness here is intentional. Studies of the likability penalty keep finding that the very same request comes across as assertive when a man makes it and as demanding when a woman does, and "presence" is a convenient place for that double standard to hide.
The test
Answer yes or no, looking back over the last month. Count only what truly happened, not what you wish you had done.
1. Lead with the recommendation itself, then walk through the logic that supports it.
2. You pushed back on someone more senior, openly, in a meeting.
3. Put your team's purpose into a single sentence that someone outside the field could follow right away.
4. Before anyone in the Austin office looks elsewhere, they tend to come to you first when something goes wrong.
5. Resist the urge to rush in and fill silence during a meeting; let the quiet sit.
6. You said "I don't know, and I'll have an answer by Thursday," and then you delivered.
7. The emails you send to senior leaders run shorter than the ones they send you.
8. When a senior colleague asked for something you couldn't do, you declined and explained yourself in one line.
9. Even in an unsettled Austin meeting room, you kept a calm and steady demeanor.
Step ten. A later meeting featured someone quoting one of your lines back to you.
Reading your score
A score of eight to ten shows you carry a clear, commanding presence. People in the room already see you as the one who decides things. If you keep receiving that feedback anyway, ask who is offering it and what they actually mean, because it may have little to do with you.
Four to seven: still growing. You have the judgment and part of the signal. What is mostly missing is speed and economy: the recommendation up front, the tighter email, the silence you leave alone while the room catches up.
Scoring between zero and three means you are capable, though you tend to keep a low profile. You do the work well and then let others in the Central Texas group figure out what it all means. Quietness of this kind is no defect of your character. Plenty of us were trained to lay out our reasoning before we had earned the conclusion, and that was sound advice for a classroom, not a boardroom.
What to do next
Eight to ten: the next time someone says "presence," ask, "What specifically would you want to see differently in the next meeting?" Write the answer down. When a reply never arrives, that silence itself tells you something about the feedback you received.
Scoring four to seven, try this for a month: begin every Pflugerville or Cedar Park update with the decision you need, stated in the opening sentence. Change nothing else. Notice how the room responds.
Scoring zero to three, at your next meeting, voice one brief disagreement to the most senior person present and then fall silent. A single line such as "I see it differently, and here's why" is all you need, and then you wait for their reply. The quiet that follows is the presence.
Count your yeses, and forward this to the woman who was told she needs more presence but never heard what that meant.