Seven pieces of "wisdom" senior women wish they had ignored
Let's refer to her as Carla. She's a composite, not a member or client of ours. At 46 she is a senior vice president, and over lunch in Austin she faces a 31-year-old manager from her own team who has just put the question to her that she once put to someone: "What's the one piece of advice you'd give me?"
Carla feels trapped. Each piece of advice she received at 31 came from a senior person who meant well and was mistaken, and she followed every bit of it. Before she can flag anything to the manager, she first needs to figure out which piece of advice did the most damage. Her list currently holds seven items. Three still make her angry.
Option A. Stay quiet and trust the work to make your case
The price: the work does not make the case. People do, and in Carla's situation the person doing the talking was her boss, who presented her work as his own for four years. She was promoted once during that stretch. He was promoted twice. According to McKinsey and LeanIn's 2025 study, 31% of women at the entry level have a sponsor, while the figure for men stands at 45%. Staying quiet and keeping a low profile is precisely what lands you in the remaining 69%.
Option B. Don't apply unless you match every line of the job posting
The price: six roles she never went after between the ages of 33 and 40. Tara Mohr's survey for Harvard Business Review found that women skip jobs they feel underqualified for largely because they treat the listed requirements as hard rules, not because they lack confidence. Carla treated them as rules. Those six jobs went to men who viewed the same kinds of lists as a roadmap for what they wanted next.
Option C. Appreciate the opportunity that came your way
The price: she was grateful with every offer, which meant she accepted every opening number. A 2023 study from Berkeley Haas reported that 54% of women negotiated their most recent offer, versus 44% of men, and women still ended up earning less. Gratitude is a feeling, not a pay strategy, and the people who urged her to feel it were not the ones signing her paychecks.
What experienced leaders advise
The other four surface whenever senior women swap stories over coffee in Round Rock or downtown. Advice like "Wait your turn" presumes a line exists and that somebody is keeping track of who is in it. "Don't come across as too ambitious," which no man over 40 has ever heard at a performance review. "Just be yourself," which is incomplete without the rest of the sentence: "and find out what that costs in this company." And the one senior women rank as the worst most often: "If you're good, people will notice." They will notice. Noticing a problem and doing something about it are two different things, and it is in the gap between them that ten years can vanish.
Some of the executives, in fairness, offer a gentler message. Not one piece of this guidance was intended to hurt her. It was offered by people who climbed to their positions along another path and took for granted that the path would still be there for her. The advice isn't false. It's a map that has gone out of date.
The verdict
Which way you lean comes down to who you had become by age 31. Should you have been speaking up already, keeping your head low will not work for long. If you were already cautious, "every requirement" will cost you most, because you will follow it perfectly. Carla gives the manager the advice she wishes she had received: "Assume no one is keeping score on your behalf, and keep the score yourself."
Poll
Of options A, B, and C, which one has cost you the most? Mail your letter to the chapter, and the results will go out in print next month. Should the worst advice you received be missing from the list, please submit that as well. We capped the list at seven purely because that is the number that fit on the page.