What a decade of "lean in" got wrong, and what actually moves women up

In Austin and across Central Texas, fifty-four percent of women said they pushed back on their latest job offer. Forty-four percent of men did. Even so, the women came away earning less. That comes from Kray, Kennedy and Lee at Berkeley Haas, released in 2023 and covered by Fortune, and it alone should put an end to a decade of advice.

The "lean in" years rested on a neat idea. The belief ran that women are paid less and promoted more slowly since they just fail to make the request. Teach women to ask better through confidence training, negotiation courses and a steady nudge to value their own worth, the thinking went, and the pay gap would narrow. For employers, that story was easy to live with, since every fix it offered was something the woman had to carry out herself. The Berkeley numbers undo it. Women are now asking more often than men, and they still land short.

Tracing the source of the figure

That study, carried out at the Haas School of Business at Berkeley, was directed by Laura Kray and worked on alongside Jessica Kennedy and Margaret Lee. Its focus was the way job candidates handled bargaining over recent offers. What caught researchers off guard was that women were more likely than men to bargain. The more important result is that they still earned less. A single study is not the final word. It does not show that women negotiate better or worse, and it does not account for every factor behind the difference. Even so, that finding undercuts the most straightforward account of the gap. You cannot pin a gap on a behavior that women are already doing more of.

Other work points in the same direction. Studies of the likability penalty have repeatedly shown that the same request sounds assertive coming from a man and demanding coming from a woman. Taken together, the evidence does not say "women don't ask." It says women ask, and the room penalizes them for it.

How this plays out on the ground

Picture yourself in Round Rock or Cedar Park, holding an offer for a position you truly want. You have reviewed three postings that list pay ranges, you know where the midpoint falls, and you request it calmly, with your reasons. The recruiter says she will "see what she can do" and returns about two thousand dollars higher, described as a real stretch. Another candidate interviewing for the same position asks for the top of the range and gets close to it, described as "competitive." You negotiated. He negotiated. The results still differ, and nothing you said on that call would have changed that, because the decision about what your request was worth had already been made before you spoke.

How this applies to your own career

If you have ever been told you need more confidence, pay attention to what that advice was really doing. The study located the gap in the individual, where closing it requires nothing from the employer. Tulshyan and Burey made a similar argument about imposter syndrome in Harvard Business Review in 2021: the label places a systemic problem on the individual. The confidence gap is the same move with different vocabulary. You do not need repairing. The workplace's pay decisions need examining.

This matters just as much in Austin. Median earnings for women in the city were $54,141 in 2024, against $68,145 for men, which works out to about 79 cents on the dollar. Those figures are a reminder that the gap is measured across the whole labor market, not in any one negotiation. A woman working in professional services downtown, in healthcare at St. David's or Ascension Seton, or in the state's and university's large workforces is still facing the same structural math.

What comes next

Ask about the band, not about your worth. "What is the posted range for this level, and where does this offer sit within it?" Posted ranges are now required in a growing number of states, so the question has a factual answer. Then ask the one question that cannot be read as a judgment of your personality: "What would it take to reach the midpoint?" You are working from the numbers, and the numbers do not come across as demanding.

If you want support as you prepare, Austin offers resources. The Women in Business Leadership Symposium, run through the McCombs school's Graduate Women in Business, and the regular ATX Women of Wealth & Worth meetups are both listed in our local calendar, and the Women's Business Center network and SCORE mentors can help with the financial side of any move.

Think back to the most recent time you made a request, and consider what that request ended up costing you.

Sources: