A scorecard for women who stopped checking years ago
The standard guidance works, but only up to a certain point, especially for Austin-area leaders. If you love what you do, pay becomes a secondary concern. A strong manager, meaningful work and colleagues you rely on are worth more than a few extra points of raise, and chasing every dollar tends to wear people down. Many women in Central Texas who switched jobs for a 15% bump now find themselves less content, just at a higher salary.
Still, there's a counterpoint worth weighing: caring about your work is precisely when you're most likely to be underpaid, because the people deciding your pay can see how little you push.
1. Loyalty is priced in
Pay isn't set by what you deserve. It's set by what it would cost to replace you, adjusted for how likely you are to walk out. McKinsey and LeanIn's 2025 report found that just 54% of companies treat women's advancement as a high priority, and the other half won't volunteer a correction. Three signs point here: you haven't had one outside conversation in three years. Each pay bump you've gotten in Austin has simply matched the usual company percentage. Nobody has ever made you a counter-offer, because you never gave anyone a reason to.
2. The work grew and the number didn't
Research for the book The No Club found that at one professional-services firm, women put in roughly 200 more hours a year than men on non-promotable work, and were asked about 50% more often. Because you care so much about your role, agreeing to extra tasks feels effortless. Look for three red flags: your duties have widened, yet your job title has never changed. You train people you suspect out-earn you. The planning, the meeting notes and the offsite keep landing on your desk, and nobody has ever tallied them.
3. The market moved while you were busy
More states now require employers to publish salary bands, so anyone in the Austin area who looks can see what the market pays, but you haven't looked yet. Three signs: a new hire at your level started above you. When a headhunter from Round Rock or Cedar Park named a number, it surprised you. You don't know the salary band for your role, let alone where you fall inside it.
Where the traditional approach still holds
Don't walk away from a job you love for an extra 5%. The advice only breaks down when it becomes an excuse to stop checking. Enjoying the work and knowing what it's worth aren't in conflict. The women in Austin who are paid well in roles they enjoy are the ones who kept their numbers current while they stayed put.
A better path forward
Rate your situation against each of the nine indicators. Three or fewer, and you're likely fine; keep checking once a year. Four to six, and your pay is drifting; spend thirty minutes this week on a market check, pulling three posted ranges for your title in the Austin metro and noting the midpoint. Seven or more, and you're effectively subsidizing your employer, and affection for the work isn't a line item on a budget.
Then bring one sentence to your manager during a regular one-on-one, without drama: "I'd like to understand where I sit in the salary range for my level, and what it would take to reach the midpoint." You aren't threatening to leave. You're asking a straightforward question about numbers, and a manager who sidesteps it has answered it anyway.
Among those nine people in the Austin area, how many did you tally?